Thursday, March 20, 2014

How the CJS manipulates Complaining Witnesses after a Domestic Violence Arrest

When someone has been arrested for a domestic violence charge, one of the key areas for legal guidance concerns what to do about a Florida no contact order. As you read this entry and watch the video below, here is your fact pattern: Complaining Witness and Defendant are drinking, have an argument, and 911 is called. The police respond, separate the parties, and start interrogating. The woman is crying, the man refuses to talk, so he goes to jail. She is devastated, and begs the police not to take him to jail. 

I could make a more interesting fact pattern, but the one shared above is one that is a daily occurrence - not "frequent," daily.

No contact orders are usually imposed as a condition of bond at first appearance. This is obviously problematic, since a) a criminal defendant is presumed innocent, yet b) he or she is kicked out of their residence after spending a night or two in jail. Since this article is designed for practical advice, I'll spare you the gender politics that led us to this highly biased and unnecessary knee jerk reaction that poisons every case. However, be advised that no contact orders are automatically imposed in every case unless the complaining witness shows up at first appearance begging for the defendant to be allowed to return home, or the defendant is somehow able to obtain legal counsel.

Usually, no contact orders are lifted at a separate hearing due to the absence of legal counsel. They are then transformed into "No Violence Contact" orders while the case is pending. This allows the parties to have nonviolent contact, and the defendant usually can then return home.

If you think the system is rigged, this area of criminal law virtually proves it: the system is set up for no contact orders as the default in every domestic violence case. Worse, the Complaining Witness is often given bad advice in order to help convict the defendant.

For example, in many cases, the Complainant is told to "go to the State Attorney's Office and ask to have it lifted" or to go there and "ask to have the charges dropped." This has the appearance of being helpful, but exposes the Complainant to outright manipulation: many are told that if they lied, that perjury is a felony. However, they are also told that if they recant, they have filed a false police report and will go to jail immediately - how do you think this impacts their statements? Worse, many are sent to "victims" propaganda classes as a condition of their request for a change in bond conditions to even be considered.

In other words, the criminal justice system is set up to manipulate to purported victims of domestic violence in the same manner that their "counseling and empowerment" classes warn about. Therefore, the best way to handle this situation is with an experienced criminal defense lawyer, preferably one who is certified as an expert in the field.


Labels: , , , , , , , ,

Tuesday, March 18, 2014

The Five Biggest mistakes people make when charged with Domestic Violence in Florida

The number of mistakes someone can make when they have been charged with domestic violence is actually unlimited. However, this short video discusses the five biggest ones.

Note: this video pertains to domestic violence assault, battery, domestic violence by strangulation, aggravated assault and aggravated battery. Sexual offenses within the domestic violence construct have not been addressed.

Someone asked me if there was one mistake that was the biggest of all of them, and I was hard pressed for an answer. After thinking about it, I've concluded that denial would have to rank as number one. Here is why:

In every type of criminal case, people often are so terrified, so out of their element, that they try to "talk their way out of the ride" to jail. Instead, they go to jail and begin making mistake after mistake. Thus Denial is the biggest mistake of them all.

As you watch the video, think about each one carefully, and you'll probably come to the same conclusion. If not, by all means, let me know, and let me know why.


Labels: , , , , , , ,

Saturday, March 15, 2014

Florida Domestic Violence Charge Defenses: Accident

There are some defenses that seem so obvious that the mere stating of them seems obvious to the point of explaining how to breathe. Accident is one of those defenses, yet it is a mistake to assume the patently obvious is patently obvious in the mine field of Florida criminal law.

The reason is simple: jury instructions. Jury instructions are a political football and domestic violence charges are a hot button issue. For this reason, it is a good thing that this defense is recognized: gender politics have thrown this defense into question.

Example: a young man is in a crowded beach bar and bumps a woman's breast with his elbow. Drunkenly enraged, she then has the bouncer grab the man for off duty police officer working at the bar. She claims he pinched her breast. At high, drunken volume.

So, the report reads as follows:

"Suspect was contacted and asked to give a statement. At no time was he under arrest. Suspect admitted "possibly bumping the woman's breast" and appeared nervous. Witnesses Jane X and Jane Y each gave statements that the suspect was standing next to the victim, apparently leering at numerous women in the club, and left rapidly after their friend was inappropriately touched upon the breast. Upon finding probable cause, the suspect was taken into custody."

Translation: This guy was arrested, taken to jail, and at the very minimum charged with a non-domestic battery for bumping a drunk woman's breast on accident. His statement was used against him, and note how the report was written to make the entire incident far more sinister than it was.

Now, imagine these domestic scenarios:

  • "throw me the lighter" becomes "threw the lighter at the victim"
  • slamming the door, as you partner unknowingly walks into it turns into "slammed the door on the victim's arm/foot/face"
  • arguing while both of you are talking with your hands turn into "slapped the victim's hand"
Fortunately, there is the defense of accidental contact. Unfortunately, it usually comes down to a swearing match. However, when skillfully used, it may result in a voluntary dismissal, but only after a lot of legal work and education of the prosecutor.


Labels: , , ,

Wednesday, March 12, 2014

Florida Domestic Violence Defenses: Mutual Combat

This is one of my favorite defenses to discuss, and it is rarely handled correctly.

First, we've already discussed Florida's "Primary Aggressor" law which means that if law enforcement is called on a domestic, someone is usually going to jail. However, this leads to a second point which is often poorly understood and not effectively taught in law enforcement seminars. Or there is a policy decision (read politics) to lock one of them up and let the court system sort it out. Either way, someone who engaged in lawful conduct - mutual combat - is arrested and now needs a criminal defense attorney licensed in Florida.

Mutual combat assumes both parties are engaged in wrongful behavior. This differs from self defense because someone engaged in self defense is, by the very nature of self defense, not guilty of the charge because they are the actual victim who is not required by law to suffer a battery.

In the domestic violence context, what often happens is that one party will make a statement such as "the other person hit/pushed/slapped/bruised/grabbed me" and leaves out the part about their mutual combat with that person. Legally, if two people want to fight each other - without causing serious injury - it is lawful. In other words, both parties decided to give consent to engage in a) intentional touching, that was b) harmful or offensive.

This type of defense may be a trial defense or in some fact patterns, actually subject to a motion to dismiss.

)

Labels: , , , , , , ,

Wednesday, February 26, 2014

Florida Domestic Violence Defenses: Did Not Happen

The most common variant of a defense that a domestic violence allegation did not happen is precisely that: nothing illegal happened.

This is a very clear defense in its purest form - the two elements of battery, intentional touching or striking that was harmful or offensive, simply did not occur. Either there was a mistake or someone lied or both.

However, many cases are not so simple. As discussed in the video below, parts of the allegations may be admitted while others are denied. Some cases are felonies, some defenses may affect other defenses or even eliminate them.

One thing is very consistent: Many are being pushed into "counseling" classes that may last for over six (6) months when they never broke the law. Worse, these classes are a prime example of the 80/20 Rule: they will help 20% of the participants and will fail 80% of the time.

You read that right - domestic violence classes have a failure rate that often exceeds 80%.

Why? Two reasons.

1) Many of the class participants should not even be there in the first place. They foolishly tried to handle the case on their own, and found themselves imprisoned in worthless rehabilitation classes for "domestic abusers" when they never committed any act of domestic violence. Of course, they are blamed for their reluctance to admit to abuse that never occurred.

2) As I have pointed out repeatedly in other posts, such as here, an accurate diagnosis is required in order for treatment to be effective. Where the diagnostic model consists of "what's your charge?" followed by the conclusion "You need domestic violence counseling!", we have a problem. Treatment is only as effective as the diagnosis. Yet Florida has the usual, feel good, one size fits all approach. Thus if a woman or a man commits an act of domestic violence and really need treatment, they get a political solution to a medical problem.

Finally, not to harp on the oft stated and blisteringly obvious, but a large part of the problem is Florida's "somebody is going to jail when the police are called on a domestic" law (determination of the "primary aggressor" by statutory requirement). As a result, mistakes are made in the field, and people are going to jail for crimes they did not commit. Yelling during an argument is turned into an assault by the legal process, despite the fact no actual assault occurred. In the same manner, snatching the keys to your own vehicle becomes a battery. When neither an assault nor a battery occurred.


Labels: , , , , , , , ,

Florida Domestic Violence Defenses: Witness will not show

The first defense in this series on Florida Domestic Violence Defenses is that the witness will not show up to court. Usually, but not always, this refers to the Complaining Witness (the State will often call this witness "the victim," which is not permissible in front of a jury).

Unfortunately, over the last two and a half decades, I have seen more unrepresented defendants blow their cases with this defense than all other defenses combined.

Although fraught with danger, many people delay hiring a skilled Florida criminal defense lawyer because they have a fantasy belief (usually the product of wishful thinking plus inexperience) about how the criminal justice system works. They sincerely believe either 1) the Complaining Witness can just decide not to testify or, 2) that the Complaining Witness has the power to unilaterally drop a domestic violence charge.


Here is what really happens: the State will subpoena the Complaining Witness and offer to put them behind bars if they refuse to testify. Since judges tend to take a dim view of witnesses blowing off a subpoena, the threat is real: people do go to jail for refusing to show up to court to testify.

The Complaining Witness does not have the power to drop the domestic violence charges. Only the State can file criminal charges and only the State can drop criminal charges. But by the time most unrepresented defendants fully appreciate this rigging of the system, their plea bargain (which is never the best one available - they have no lawyer, so no realistic threat of trial) is revoked. Now they face a lifetime of legal harassment for having a domestic on their record or a lifetime of harassment and jail time.

The mechanism to compel testimony against someone's will is usually a Motion for an Order to Show Cause (why the witness should not be held in contempt of court). This motion is routinely granted when a witness does not show up for a domestic violence trial. If found to be in contempt of court, the witness will be punished in some manner. This threat is how the Complaining Witness is coerced into testifying against their will.

Key point: the witness will be told not to commit perjury (a felony), but also will be told that if they change their story (often admitting the truth about what really happened), they will go to jail on the spot for Filing a False Police Report. Although very few Complaining Witnesses are ever charged, the threat produces the desired result: coerced testimony. The unrepresented defendant usually finds this out at the last moment, and a plea of guilty or no contest is crushed out of them by a prosecutor who knows how to work the system.

Final Note: this defense will work, but don't screw up your case and then call a lawyer - by then it is too late. Problems do not get better with time. Act quickly, and avoid the land mines in the legal minefield of criminal law.

Labels: , , , , , ,

Tuesday, February 25, 2014

Florida Domestic Violence Defenses: Definitions

Definitions are extremely important. How things are defined can determine how a case result is obtained - or not. Therefore, a quick video primer on Florida Domestic Violence Law definitions is extremely important.

Note: Florida Criminal Law contains numerous definitions and to cover all of them would take an eternity. So, only the basics are covered here.

One of my favorite examples definitional disaster involves "assault and battery" since the phrase is commonly misused, and gives the impression that they are one and the same. However, assault is not a battery and a battery is not an assault. The penalties alone are strikingly different, even in the context of a criminal misdemeanor: assault can result in sixty (60) days in jail; battery, up to a year. The simplest way to describe the difference is to liken assault with a swing and a miss, and battery as a swing that hits. This is grossly oversimplified, but gives a good mental visual of the difference between the two.


Labels: , , , , , , , ,

Monday, February 24, 2014

Florida Domestic Violence Defenses: Introduction

This is the first in a series of videos discussing common domestic violence defenses in Florida. This is not an exclusive list by any means. There are many defenses that aren't covered, but this gives an idea of how criminal defense lawyers handle such cases.

The basics of defending assault and battery are covered, but sexual offenses in the domestic context will be dealt with in another series.


Labels: , , , , , ,

Saturday, February 15, 2014

Domestic Violence Trial: Dismissed

No court on Monday. No jury selection, no battery trial. Why? A prosecutor did the right thing. After far more months of effort than it should have required:

Full case number, personal identification information and fact pattern redacted. Here is the problem with Florida criminal law. 

This domestic violence case should have never been charged. However, it really isn't the police officer's fault: they are required by statute to determine a "primary aggressor" and then somebody is going to jail. That's the law in Florida. If the police are called on a domestic, someone goes to jail.

And when it was investigated, guess what we learned: "the witness did not observe the events that occurred within the premises."  

Also - this is omitted from the Nolle Prosequi -  there was no "victim" in the case, thus no desire to testify. 

The State really tried to crush a Pre-Trial Diversion out of my client. This is now a common practice of how bad cases are handled by the government - a diversion offer where there should be an unconditional dismissal. We had to fight for this result.

Yet at the end of the day, because we were absolutely ready for trial, for the second time in two weeks, a false domestic violence charge was dismissed. When confronted with the facts, the State Attorney agreed to do the right thing on a charge they prosecute seriously.

Labels: , , , , , ,

Friday, January 31, 2014

Chronic stress, economics, crime and social order

Many of the cases I handle as a criminal defense lawyer in Florida are rooted in chronic stress. Consider:
  • a couple has chronic stress related to money, and they fight and argue until a real or fabricated case of domestic violence erupts
  • someone making over $20/hour in 2007 goes through a long period of unemployment, and by 2014, is barely employed and making less than half of what they made seven years ago. They begin drinking heavily and ultimately get charged with DUI.
  • broke his entire adult life, a desperate twenty-five year old male robs a convenience store.
  • a teenager watches his parents lose their jobs, their home, and barely survive on the margins, living minimum wage paycheck to paycheck, desperately poor and with no hope for a better tomorrow. Sinking into depression and anxiety, a gun is taken to school and, you can figure out the rest.
This is America today.

There is a mass homicide such as the shootings at Sandy Hook roughly every two weeks. As awful as such events are, isn't there are part of you that doesn't get surprised by this?

Moralists are quick to prescribe nonsensical quick fixes with one line sentences of pithy rhetoric, usually some form of childish black and white thinking which does little more than display a profound level of ignorance about the human condition.

Reality can be brutal: people without hope are dangerous. When their brains are scanned and the images are compared with healthy, normal range brain images, people who have been under chronic stress have negative changes to both the physical structure and operational parameters of their most important organ in the human body. The organ that controls human behavior. Or not.

When PTSD is factored in, the result can be terrifying. When all forms of mental illness are factored in, as a society, we have to confront uncomfortable truths:

1) The people who are completely insane (what I loosely and unscientifically refer to as the "I think I am Jesus" category) they are not the problem. When someone is babbling nonsense claiming to be the messiah, discerning mental illness requires little skill simply because it is so obvious. And they are not the biggest threat. The ones that fly under the radar and appear to be somewhat normal, yet eccentric are extremely dangerous. Punishment does not deter them. Think of the Boston Bomber suspect who made headlines (again) today with the announcement the government is seeking the death penalty. How well did that threat of punishment work?

2) We are our brotherss (and our sisters') keeper. Unless we embrace and support a total breakdown of social order, mass homicides, bombings, Santa Slayers and a whole host of simply awful social ramifications.

Fortunately, we can solve these seemingly intractable problems with an investment in our people, despite the unpopularity of talking about income inequality and the fact that crime is a medical problem. It has been reported that 400 Americans have a level of wealth equal to the lower 150 million in our country, and worldwide, that 85 people have half of the world's wealth. Quick point: when was the last time you heard about a billionaire losing it and committing a mass homicide? How about a robbery?

You haven't. It doesn't happen.

In America, when half of the country has no realistic way to compete for a bigger slice of the economic pie, and the slice they have is getting smaller, it is easy to foresee that more mental breakdowns will occur.

Along with Greece, Spain, Ukraine and a host of other nations, Britain had a complete mental breakdown due to the chronic stress of economic anxiety in 2011: do we want that to happen here?

Decidedly not. Preachy moralisms are no answer. We either care for our brothers and sisters with our economic, social, criminal, medical, and taxation policies or we live with the consequences of our continuing failure to do so.

Labels: , , , , , ,

Wednesday, January 29, 2014

Florida Assault Law as explained by this criminal defense attorney

Occasionally, I take the suit off. On this day, the video was produced with Lisa Northern Photography from Atlanta.
Florida Assault Law is often confused with the law of Florida regarding battery. This is why you often hear people speak of "assault and battery" as if they are the same thing.

Either an assault or a battery can be a form of domestic violence, and come in many different permutations. And they are extremely common because Florida law practically insures that if the police are called on a domestic, somebody is going to jail. My jury selection Monday? Allegations of domestic violence as noted in my prior post.

Labels: , , , ,

Monday, January 27, 2014

False Domestic Violence Charges should be dismissed before trial

So . . . ready for trial is announced on Final Plea Day (not to be confused with the erroneously labelled "Plea Day" in Okaloosa County which is actually arraignment court).

In this particular Domestic Violence case, the writing has been on the wall for some time: "[H]e did not hit me" in a written statement, confirmed in person by the State, is usually a sign that the prosecution has a real problem.

As in they will not even come close to proving the case. Yet here I am, loaded for bear, as one lawyer put it, right after court:
What is wrong with this picture taken after court this morning, besides having to wear a super serious Jury Selection suit, a cheesy smile and lower my hair? Is it the weekend spent preparing for trial, all for nothing? No. Not at all.

What's wrong with this picture is that my client was forced to risk jail time for a crime he did not commit. 

What's wrong with this picture is that the politically correct "plea bargain" the State wanted included fines, court costs, cost of supervision, and twenty-six (26) weeks of "domestic abuser" counseling for a crime they know he did not commit.

What's wrong with this picture is that I was even at the courthouse for this appearance to pick a jury on a trash case: there were over fifty (50) cases on the docket for a two (2) week trial calendar and there is no way fifty cases are going to get tried in a two week period. Jurors were called, their time set on fire, and case after case was dismissed.

What's really, really wrong with this picture is that Domestic Legal Violence against innocent people is out of control. Oh - and that I have another case, in the same courthouse with a similar fact pattern next week.

Domestic Violence is a serious social, legal, political, moral and criminal justice problem. False Domestic Violence charges are just as big of a problem, but we aren't hearing about it. False allegations of Domestic Violence are just not taken seriously by the criminal justice system. Lip service doesn't count. Especially when this man was wondering all weekend if something could go wrong, and a group of strangers might actually convict him, a judge might send him to jail, and because of the nature of a domestic violence conviction, if his military related career would be history before he was released.

Upon reviewing the facts of this case, a Nolle Prosequi dismissing this case should have been filed weeks ago. Instead, taxpayer money and people's most valuable asset - their time - was wasted. 

Note: not all prosecutors use this bullying tactic to crush a plea out of someone for a non-existent crime. I know several who do not. 

Yet far too many do.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Friday, January 24, 2014

Arrested on vacation in Destin, Florida

Each year, many people coming to Destin, Florida, on vacation end up in jail. Getting arrested on your vacation in Destin is probably the last thing on someone's mind. No one wakes up in the morning excited about getting arrested and going to jail, in my experience.

However, there are actually some advantages to living outside of the area if your legal team knows how Okaloosa (or Walton, if you are across the county line to the east) County's criminal justice system operates. The two most common arrests? DUI and Domestic Violence.

Labels: , , ,

Wednesday, January 22, 2014

Advanced Plea Bargaining in Florida Criminal Cases.

Advanced Plea Bargaining using SPECT (Single Photon Emission Computed Tomography) brain imaging based Diagnostic Evaluations and Treatment plans. This short video explains something I am deeply passionate about: solving the problem of crime.

Treating the problem of crime is far more effective than jail or prison, whether someone has a prior record or is a first offender seeking mitigation of sentence.

Labels: , , , , , ,

Tuesday, January 14, 2014

Florida Criminal Law Specialist




This just arrived, and I have to say it gives me a great deal of satisfaction: this is the third cycle of continuous certification as a specialist in criminal law since 2002.

This came the other day, along with my letter notifying me that I had successfully re-certified, and this is one of the most rewarding achievements of my career.

Some criminal defense lawyers may sweat their online reivews, others may want to be a "SuperLawyer," but those in the know look for the initials "BCS" or the logo for the expert designation. From DUI to Domestic Violence, Theft to Trespass, whatever the crime charged, when it comes to prosecution and defense of criminal cases, a lawyer is either Board Certified or not.

This is the capstone of a lawyer's career, the review that counts.

Many "recognition" marks are just marketing spam, to put it bluntly. To become Board Certified, you have been tested in the toughest arena: among your peers, in battle.

All lawyers should aspire to become Board Certified. Certification should be the rule, not the exception.

Yet less than 0.5% of Florida lawyer are certified in criminal law.

Labels: , , , , ,